Monday, May 15, 2023

Carolina Raptor Center Notes on Piper Glen Eagles May 15th Update

We appreciate Bob with the Carolina Raptor Center sharing his "field notes" once again from his usual Monday visit.

The photo courtesy of Emilie Knight all rights are reserved. 

Hope you enjoy Bob's observations and commentary. 

We continue to work to protect wildlife in the Rea Road area and encourage Charlotte City Council to embrace smart growth protecting all wildlife. 

OBSERVER: Bob

NEST LOCATION: Piper Glen

DATE OF VISIT: 05/15/2023

TIME OF VISIT:11:00 AM – 12:45 PM

WEATHER CONDITIONS: 72 F; wind 7mph ESE; mostly sunny

BAEA’s PRESENT: Yes; 2 eaglets & 2 mature BAEAs

OBSERVATION NOTES:

Ugh! Another Monday tournament and a full parking lot. I slipped past the golfers and got out onto the dam. From the dam I sighted a BAEA perched in the favored tree across the reservoir ready to pluck a fish from the water. 

From the dam I spotted an eaglet in the nest. It was tearing at some food in the nest. I was amazed when I saw it try to swallow what looked like an entire squirrel, although it also looked like a string of sausages. I watched as it repeatedly threw its head back over a span of 5 minutes as it moved around the nest and tried to down its meal. When it finally got that down it immediately picked up what appeared to be a whole fish and again tried to force it down. It took a while and it then flew up above the nest and perched. There was no sight of the second eaglet in the nest. 

A BAEA appeared and flew loops around the nest tree vocalizing all the while. It then perched beyond the golf cart path. I moved to the lower level, careful to avoid the torrent of golf balls raining down on the driving range. I watched the nest from the area of the small pond where there was an unobstructed view of the nest. 

A second BAEA flew to the nest area with something in its talons. It perched above the nest and I could see the fish on the limb. It seemed to be trying to urge the eaglet to come for lunch.

Of course, this eaglet had just gorged itself and probably couldn’t fit anything else in its crop. 

Without a response from the eaglet it soon flew away. The mate then flew to the nest and there was lots of keening from the eaglet. I do believe that the parents were trying to urge this eaglet to flee the nest, but it wasn’t cooperating.

The BAEA then flew from the nest to the tree line along the creek. I walked beyond the golf cart path to look for the second eaglet, but had no luck. 

As I looked back toward the dam I spotted the second eaglet perched in the tallest tree along the creek. So, we now know that one eaglet has fledged and I would guess the second one has or is about to. Both BAEAs disappeared from my view. 

The two eaglets remained on their respective perches as I left the property.

Thursday, May 4, 2023

Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Update No. 9

 MAY 4, 2023  


On April 19th, Charlotte City Council Member Ed Driggs sent out an email that offered what appeared to be dramatic and encouraging news regarding the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Request:

“I have been advised that Charlotte planning staff, up to and including the Planning Director, have communicated their strong opposition to rezoning petition 2022-121 as submitted by RK Investments Charlotte LLC.  

The staff position was based on many of the same concerns I had expressed in my first meeting with the petitioner, and which you have all communicated so clearly to me and the petitioner since then.  

Staff made some suggestions for a dramatically different approach to development including a mix of housing types with minimal if any apartments.  They also suggested that the petitioner try harder to achieve some kind of alignment with residents before submitting any further proposals."  

Councilmember Driggs went on to state:

“I had indicated to you previously that I thought the staff analysis might serve as a wakeup call for the petitioner and that residents should wait to see how that turns out before engaging in any further in opposition to this proposal.  Based on the staff response and my own clearly stated opposition, I can safely say there is no chance the petition will be approved in anything like its current form.”  

At the time the email seemed at least on the surface very promising.

Yet the City of Charlotte Planning Staff website offered no indication of the same or even remotely similar sentiment. 

Last Saturday Councilmember Driggs held a “coffee” billed as a town hall meeting with “topics for discussion” including rezoning petitions and decisions.

Sadly Mr. Driggs “town hall” was really just a "dog and pony show" where few questions were permitted. This included a long presentation regarding Northwood Development’s “Ballantyne Reimagined” project which was nothing more than a "progress pep rally" which was preceded by a detailed review of Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools construction projects.

Throughout the three-hour meeting with 200 people in attendance no more than a half dozen questions were permitted.

When I rose to ask the Charlotte Planning spokesperson about the planning department’s website and if it was up to date with regards to the Gillespie Property, I was told by Councilmember Driggs to sit down and that they were not going to debate the Gillespie Property. 

On Monday I emailed the City Planning Staff with regards to Councilmember Driggs email of 19 April, asking if Mr. Driggs statements were accurate.

This is the response:

"We have reviewed two versions of their site plan thus far.  In both reviews we have asked that they reduce their building height to 65 ft. We have also noted that the Policy Map recommends Neighborhood 1 Place type and have told them during comment review meetings that they need to make revisions to the plan to better align with the recommended place type.  

Staff can only require changes made to plans to ensure Ordinance compliance.  

Our other comments such as aligning with the recommended place type are requests and the petitioner can choose to work to address those requests or not.   If the petitioner chooses to not to or not fully address the requests then our goal would be to get to the best possible plan the petitioner is agreeable to. If they’ve make changes staff would review and determine if they were sufficient to warrant a positive recommendation.

I haven’t spoken to or heard from them since our last set of comments were provided on March 1st so I’m not sure what direction they may be taking at this point."

On Monday evening I emailed Councilmember Driggs asking if he could explain the apparent conflict and why the planning staff’s opinion of the project didn't seem to align with his personal “take” on the project.

Four days later with no response I must assume that there is little if any merit to Mr. Driggs' email regarding the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning request.

Clearly this is a disappointing revelation.

What is even more concerning is that Mr. Diggs would suggest ”residents should wait to see how that turns out before engaging in any further opposition to this proposal” in other words “sit down and shut up”. 

Collectively we wait for an explanation from Mr. Driggs. 

In the meanwhile we continue to vigorously oppose the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Request and seek alternative solutions to the development of this untouched natural habitat inside the 485 beltway.

Again, thank you for your continued support and sharing this petition with neighbors, friends and family.

Footnote: Norman Rockwell's painting “Freedom of Speech” (published by the “The Saturday Evening Post” more than 80 years ago) depicting Rockwell's own town hall meeting, seemed fitting.  


Wednesday, April 19, 2023

CLTCC Ed Driggs: Update on the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning

The following email was received from Charlotte City Council Member Ed Driggs this morning Wednesday April 19, 2023


 To all,


I have been advised that Charlotte planning staff, up to and including the Planning Director, have communicated their strong opposition to rezoning petition 2022-121 as submitted by RK Investments Charlotte LLC.  The staff position was based on many of the same concerns I had expressed in my first meeting with the petitioner, and which you have all communicated so clearly to me and the petitioner since then.  Staff made some suggestions for a dramatically different approach to development including a mix of housing types with minimal if any apartments.  They also suggested that the petitioner try harder to achieve some kind of alignment with residents before submitting any further proposals.  

I had indicated to you previously that I thought the staff analysis might serve as a wake up call for the petitioner and that residents should wait to see how that turns out before engaging in any further in opposition to this proposal.  Based on the staff response and my own clearly stated opposition, I can safely say there is no chance the petition will be approved in anything like its current form.  

There is no indication yet of how the petitioner intends to proceed based on the staff analysis.  Based on the large disparity between the current petition and the view staff and I have on what might be appropriate at that location, the time line leading up to any Council decision has now gotten longer, probably by several months at least.  

If any individual or group among you would like to discuss what solution might be workable at the site, I am happy to attend a meeting or talk on the phone.  

My cell number is (704) 574-7262.


Ed Driggs


Charlotte City Council District 7

(704) 432-7077

Tuesday, April 18, 2023

Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Update No. 8

Our Rea Road GIllespie Property Rezoning Petition requesting Charlotte City Council Members VOTE NO has surpassed more than 10,000 signatures.

Our photo for this update was taken by TPC Piper Glen Golf Course Director of Grounds Steffie Safrit 
showing the flooding that occured on March 27, 2023.


We continue to communicate with City of Charlotte staff regarding the rezoning of the GIllespie Property. As of this past Friday the developer had not responded to City of Charlotte staff requests for corrections, changes, clarifications and modifications.  In short the rezoning request is on hold until they do.

Piper Glen's Old St. Andrews HOA will hold their annual meeting this Thursday (April 20, 2023) at the South County Library 5801 Rea Road Charlotte NC 28277 from 6:00 PM until 7:30 PM while the rezoning issue is not on the agenda it is likely that the Gillespie Property will come up. (Open to OSA property owners only.)

Charlotte City Council Member Ed Driggs will hold a "coffee" on Saturday April 29th from 9 AM - 12 Noon 

Location St. Matthew Catholic Church 
8515 Ballantyne Commons Parkway 
Charlotte, NC 28277

Mr. Driggs has listed his topics for discussion as follows:

Property Tax Revaluation 
UDO Implementation of June 1st (Unified Development Ordinance
Rezoning Petitions & Decisions 
CDOT & NCDOT Road Project Updates
CMPD Safety and Crime Updates
Ballantyne Reimagined Projects & Development
School Construction Projects


While Mr. Driggs does not specifically mention the Gillespie Property we imagine it will be addressed. 

The meeting is open to the public.

We also continue to pursue the idea of creating a "Nature Preserve" from the Gillespie Property in whole or part with the help of Mecklenburg County and if needed via a private / public partnership.

What used to be a once every other year event has now become a several times a year event. This is largely due to over development within South Charlotte and throughout the Rea Road Neighborhoods.

You can find more information the Gillespie Property Rezoning, traffic, flooding, and our Eagles, Piper and Glen at Rea Road Neighborhood Coalition we appreciate your continued support.

Our Mission:

We encourage "Smart Growth" in South Charlotte by denying zoning changes that add to density saturation, as well as the protection of wildlife and our quality of life. 

 

Sunday, April 16, 2023

Carolina Raptor Center Notes on Piper Glen Eagles

We appreciate Bob with the Carolina Raptor Center sharing his "field notes" from his visit last week. Hope you enjoy Bob's observations and commentary. 

We continue to work to protect wildlife in the Rea Road area and encourage Charlotte City Council to embrace smart growth protecting all wildlife.

The photo below is courtesy of Emilie Knight and all rights are reserved. 

CAROLINA RAPTOR CENTER

BALD EAGLE NEST OBSERVATION NOTES

OBSERVER: Bob

NEST LOCATION: Piper Glen Golf Club (Driving Range) 4300 Piper Glen Dri

DATE OF VISIT: 04/11/2023

TIME OF VISIT: 6:35 PM – 8:15 PM

WEATHER CONDITIONS: 69 F; wind 3mph SSW; Sunny

BAEA’s PRESENT: Yes; 2 BAEAs & 2 Eaglets

OBSERVATION NOTES:

March 20, 2023 Eagle Glen bringing home dinner to Piper with one of two eaglets visible. 

As I walked from the parking lot onto the cart path I was startled by a BAEA flying

from one of the trees nearby the clubhouse. It flew over the reservoir and headed in
the direction of the nest tree. I walked out onto the dam looking for a sighting
location for the nest that was not obscured by the leaves. 

I found it a little more than halfway along the dam and set up my scope. I sighted in and could see the tip of a head of an eaglet.

After watching the nest for a prolonged period I decided that I might get a better
view of the nest from down below near the small pond. I found a wide open view
of the nest from close to the bank of the pond and could see the head of an eaglet
poking above the nest. Again after prolonged viewing, the eaglet raised itself onto
the top of the nest and began exercising its wings. 

After a while the second eaglet began to make its presence known. By this time eaglet #1 began to jump up and down while flapping its wings. It appeared as though it was jumping on a trampoline and was pretty funny to watch. Eaglet # 2 joined in with its sibling and
began its wing exercises.

Around this time I sighted a BAEA perched beyond the golf cart path high in a
dead tree. The sun was still above the tree line and the BAEA seemed to be
relishing the last few rays of sunshine facing directly into it. Based on its size I
believe it was Piper the female.

As the sun was beginning to dip below the tree line I decided to move to the dam
once again. The eaglets remained quite active in the nest and one seemed enamored
with moving sticks around in the nest. I began to scan the reservoir area with my
binoculars and sighted a BAEA on the favored perch across the reservoir from the
clubhouse. I presumed it was Glen, the male, looking for an evenin
g snack for the
nestlings. He remained at that location for the duration of my visit.

The eaglets were becoming even more active in the nest and appeared to be finding
morsels of food that they may have previously overlooked. At one point the more
dominant eaglet appeared to be bullying the other. Perhaps sensing the hunger of
her offspring, Piper flew to Glen’s location and sat beside him on the perch. She
remained there for a few minutes and then flew to a sentry perch above the nest.
As darkness began to fall I decided to take my leave. 

Happy to see that all was well at Piper Glen with the eaglets robust and active.  


Sunday, April 2, 2023

Rea Road Gillespie Rezoning Update No. 7


Good Morning,

Our VOTE NO Petition to Charlotte City Council is only 619 signatures away from 10,000!

Meanwhile volunteers continue to explore other options to the proposed development, including having Mecklenburg County Park and Rec acquire the Gillespie Property to preserve the natural habit as it is now.

We are also currently waiting on the developer to resubmit updated plans and respond to Charlotte City Staff requests for changes. There has been no update since March 1st.

Major concern is the flawed traffic study submitted by the developer. 

The developer has stated " impact on traffic would be minimal" based on their traffic study showing an increase of 4,970 vehicle movements daily.

Yet the City's own guidelines suggest that a 1,100 unit multifamily complex would generate an additional 7,432 vehicle movements daily at a minimum.

This, added to the NC DOT 2018 traffic count of 31,000 and we are above a projected traffic count of more than 38,000 daily, an increase of more than 23%. Hardly a minimal impact.

We continue to encourage you to share this petition with your friends and neighbors in the hope that we can convince Charlotte City Council that the Rea Road GIllespie Property rezoning petition should be denied.

Friday, March 31, 2023

Letter to Raptor Center

We were fortunate to have Charlotte's local National Public Radio Station WFAE take an interest in our concern for our two resident Bald Eagles. When the WFAE reporter said he was going to meet with the staff at the Carolina Raptor Center to understand more about the American Bald Eagle I assumed this was good news. I could have not be more wrong and disappointed.

From Nick's broadcast:

Inside the Carolina Raptor Center in Huntersville, President and CEO Erin Katzner checks on a pair of disabled eagles in an enclosure. She said Mecklenburg County has more bald eagles than you might think.

"I know that we have some on Mountain Island Lake, there's some up on Lake Norman. If there's good habitat, there's very likely to be bald eagles nesting in the area," she said.

The last measurement of Charlotte’s tree canopy found it has shrunk to cover 45% of the city, down from 49% a decade ago. Katzner said habitat loss is a concern, but also said bald eagles are skilled at adapting.

"You know, I've seen bald eagles live in fairly developed areas, and fairly undeveloped areas, so it's really hard to say if it's going to be an issue for those birds, and what exactly would need to be done to prevent it from being an issue," she said.

She thought there were a few steps the developer could take.

"If it were me, I would probably want to protect that lake, protect that water system, which I imagine they would want to anyway, and ensure that some of those large trees remain standing," she said.

Obviously those of us who are very concerned about our Eagles "Glen" and "Piper" were stunned. Erin Katzner could not have been more dismissive. The raptor center director basically tossed us and our birds under the passing CATS bus.

Chip Starr's response to her on air comments is as follows unedited.


Erin,

I just wanted to make you aware that the habitat we feel is at risk cannot be preserved by the developer ensuring that "some of those large trees remain standing".

 

As an example of what is at risk is a developer's project approved by the City of Charlotte last year and less than one mile west, that was once 53 acres of native North Carolina Forest.

 

Here is the before:


Screenshot (1027).png

and the unfortunate situation one year later.

Screenshot (1028).png

Even developers who promise to preserve trees pay only minimum fines if they don't, and the truth is developers of large projects seldom save trees and that clearly would be an issue.

  
While Bald Eagles are indeed admirably adaptive, we are fairly certain that the projected five - seven years of heavy construction while completing the eight apartment buildings, that will tower over 65 feet can not be mitigated with a couple of large trees and a dredged pond with a fountain.

Yes, there are eagles at Mountain Island Lake and a reported pair at the far northern end of the Lake Norman area, but that is hardly more than most people might think are in Mecklenburg County.

 

The North Carolina Wildlife Commission says there are 400 known eagles in the state and to me that seems substantially limited compared to say Florida's 1,500. More objectively with 100 counties and 400 known Bald Eagles, North Carolina has exactly four eagles per county which again doesn't seem like a lot to me.

 

Furthermore, the Mountain Island area you mentioned to WFAE is surrounded by nearly 2,000 acres of Mecklenburg County Forest and Nature Preserves. While here in south Charlotte there is the Big Rock Nature Preserve that has a nominal 18 acres, add that to a few miles of rather polluted trash strewn Four Mile and McAlpine Greenways and anyone with even limited common sense would understand this developer’s project is a terrible idea. 

 

Obviously, I'm rather surprised that you would trivialize our concerns not only for this nesting pair of Bald Eagles but for all wildlife and the challenges nature is facing within the southern part of Mecklenburg County. 

 

Frankly, I expected more from the Raptor Center in the way of advocacy.

 

Regards

 

Chip Starr

Perhaps a little harsh, she never responded. 
The staff at the Raptor Center are wonderful and dedicated. We have applauded their efforts in the past and will continue to do so in the future. For now we must accept the fact that Erin Katzner is an insufferable twit who has just cost the Carolina Raptor Center one of the  biggest potential donation sources they could have hoped for, the 854 homeowners of Piper Glen.