Wednesday, February 21, 2024

Ed Driggs Idea of a "Tree Save" Endhaven

The phrase "Tree Save" we hear a lot. Charlotte City Council and others within our local government are worried about our "Tree City" status.

We have boards, commissions, and even a Tree Czar and two dozen staffers.

But when it comes to development not so much.

Case in point Endhaven and Elm Lane.

Councilman Ed Driggs described the project as good land use. 

“I will note that there are concerns on Endhaven about traffic safety at the junction with Elm and in general about the growth of traffic because of school development along there. CDOT is working on that. I will continue to follow it but this is a good petition. It should pass.” 

Ed Driggs might as well told a group of "angry termites" to have at it because that was all it took to wipe out nearly 10 acres of old growth forest.

This is what his yes vote did to the once thick stand of trees at the corner of Elm Lane and Endhaven.


Elm Lane at Endhaven May of 2022



Elm Lane at Endhaven February 20, 2024







But it is not just about the trees.

As one neighbor said:

Despite what this short piece states, and what Ed "Rubber Stamp" Driggs posts, wouldn't it be interesting to find out what the actual traffic congestion situation is on Endhaven Lane before they go and jam even more unaffordable development into the area.

Six dense neighborhoods feed exclusively onto mile-long, two-lane Endhaven, as do two huge schools (a third one is being built now also). Endhaven connects two busy local thoroughfares, with two huge apartment complexes and two hotels.

The idea that this newly approved development will add only 355 "vehicle trips" and twelve students is borderline silly.

What, exactly, is CDOT "working on"? And now that the new development is approved by the city council and the zoning committee, what difference will it make?

Maybe you could serve the local population by reporting on the effects of "cumulative traffic congestion" on Charlotte streets, or the lack of affordable housing being built into these over-dense, high-priced new developments. Or, the ineffectual city council and zoning committee.

Thank about it next time you're stuck in traffic.

C, Mukkigan May 31, 2022

Thursday, February 15, 2024

"By Right" What It Really Means to the Rea Road Gillespie Property

We’ve been hearing an awful lot about "By Right" development in fact that phrase has been batted around like a pickle ball for months. 





The statements by the developer that "400 dwelling units can be currently developed by right" and Councilmember Driggs, "a possible by-right development that could include only half as many trees and minimal traffic improvements" are indeed concerning. (See Mr. Driggs full statement below)

But what is the real story? What exactly does “By Right” allow:

Density: Had the Rea Road Gillespie Property been developed years ago under the current R-3 zoning with 53 acres we would have something around 50 homes of comparable size, layout and in a similar style to nearby neighborhoods. 

By the numbers under R-3, 53 acres might have yielded as many as 159 homes. Now under N1-A (The new less restrictive zoning) the developer could make them all triplexes. Translation 159 x 3 and the developer could build as many as 477 units.

However, the FEMA Floodplain, Four Mile Creek, Topography, a Required minimal tree save, Required open spaces, Curb and Gutters, plus CFD requirements for vehicle movement. Once all of this is accounted for, the actual number is closer to 400 units and perhaps “By Right” even a lower density. Which would align more closely with the density of the neighboring properties.
 
Rentals: N1-A prohibits multi-family rental apartments. “By Right” the developer cannot build rental apartments. 

Building Height: “By Right” under N1-A the developer is limited to 48’ and cannot build the 65’ tall apartment buildings being requested.  

Traffic Improvements: Even if the property is never developed, the traffic is still going to be bad. The improvements outlined by the developer do not alone fix current traffic issues, nor will they even come close to offsetting the additional demand that 640 units will cause.

Some of the offered traffic “improvements” are nonsensical and some will even make traffic worse. Those outlined on the property for ingress and egress are nominal.  

“By Right” many of the offered traffic improvements are still required.

Tree Save: The developer has offered a "possible 30% tree save" which would include only the trees in the FEMA Floodplain and a very narrow 50" buffer along the southern edge of the property.

As "By Right" the development would require only a minimum 15% tree save but since the FEMA Floodplain would still be unbuildable it is likely the entire FEMA area would remain undisturbed.

As proposed the only areas spared are the FEMA Floodplain and the 50" buffer. We lose all the trees along Rea Road and Elm Lane either way.

It is of course entirely possible the developer would destroy all but 15% of the trees in the FEMA Floodplain out of spite or anger. 

The bottom line is that “By Right” 400 homes that are not rental apartments, nor taller than 48' with considerably less traffic, and the FEMA area tree save, is far better than a rezoning that allows 640 mostly rental apartments in 65' tall buildings and with even considerably more traffic and the same or just about the same tree save.

Please take a moment today and email Charlotte City Councilmember Ed Driggs Ed.Driggs@charlottenc.gov and tell him: 

“Developing the Rea Road Gillespie Property "by-right" with no concessions is the better option than allowing the rezoning to go forward for the residents of our community and our Eagles Piper and Glen.”

Ed Driggs: "As I have noted previously, the final decision about this petition may come down to a difficult choice between whatever final proposal may be offered by RK Investments and a possible by-right development that could include only half as many trees and minimal traffic improvements.  I am somewhat concerned about the latter possibility, but I will not support the petition if residents consider the options carefully and remain united in opposition."



Tuesday, February 13, 2024

Charlotte Residents Speak Up! But is Charlotte City Council Listening?

 

"I ride this trail and hate traffic."

Wendy Segreti




 "Charlotte needs affordable housing and to maintain its tree canopy. This development accomplishes neither."











Kelsey Foxon

 

"Completely agree. It will be a complete disruption of an already delicate ecosystem. These animals will have nowhere to go.  Not to mention the incredible toll on public infrastructure such as healthcare/hospitals, schools, traffic, parking, etc."

Danay Houser

 

"More thought needs to be given to impact on roads, schools, lack of access to public transportation that works, in fact, infrastructure in general rather than allowing city planners to let developers build anywhere and everywhere with little or no regards to these important issues."

Joan Rudie

 

 


 

"The environmental impact of removing this wildlife area is concerning. This area is biodiverse and offers shelter to the natural that we all need around us to live fulfilling lives."

 

 

 

 







Michaelann Carlin

You can view the rest of the comments here

Saturday, February 10, 2024

Traffic

If you're like me you often find comfort in familiar places or songs. I drive around Charlotte and find nothing is familiar and that the rudeness of Charlotte's transplant drivers is appalling. 

I'm asked often what do I think about all the growth in Charlotte? My answer is always the same "I cry a lot." 

Yes, I'm that rare Charlotte Native, American by Birth and Southern by the Grace of God. 

So yeah I'm old and I'm jaded and have "The Low Spark" by Traffic is on my spotify. It runs 11:42 which is how long it used to take me to get to my parent's farm in Waxhaw. It now takes me nearly forty minutes (See Closer to Home Grand Funk Railroad 44:27)

But it's not the small town feel of a Southern City that I miss or the lack of familaty of a street I've traveled a thousand times that makes me weep. It is the utterly insane lack of planning our Charlotte City Council has put upon our citizens with absolutely zero understanding of our traffic in South Charlotte.

It is not just Charlotte City Council, blame belongs to Developers, CDOT and NCDOT as well, for they are masters of mediocrity. 

Now consider this, there are 15 development projects either approved and under construction or rezoning petitions up for approval that will generate at minimum 65,381 Vehicle Trips Per Day in South Charlotte alone!

We could discuss the method of calculating VTD (Vehicle Trips Daily) and point out the single family homes account for 10 while apartments only account for 4.2 but let's use their formula and save the argument that a condo owner age 30 is more likely to make multiple outings daily than a  retired couple who live at their beach house half the year. But there's no point. Let's just say the numbers are crazy low and far from any real life numbers.


Charlotte traffic is a mess. Roads that should have been improved years ago are still decades away from from even consideration of improvement. Most of Charlotte's roads are state controlled and Raleigh hates Charlotte. So for some reason Charlotte City Council creates problems that they can't even fix.

Here are the traffic study numbers in the 28277 zip code for projects under construction or up for consideration. If they are all completed and approved your Charlotte City Council will dump another 65,381 cars on South Charlotte streets within the next 18-24 months.


The largest of these projects is the Northwood "redevelopment" of Ballantyne the former Bissell property and golf course which will add 41,618 cars daily to the already jammed Johnston Road / Lancaster Highway spilling east along Endhaven to Elm Lane and north towards Highway 51. Ed Driggs actually supported this and invited Northwood to a "coffee" where the poor guy was booed and needed a police escort to leave St. Matthews Church. 

If you needed any example of why new and improved is not necessarily better look at Ballantyne Commons Parkway and Johnston Road, where Northwood eliminated the steel traffic signal poles and replaced them with wires. 

You might also notice cuts in the landscaping maintenance along Johnston Road and 485 or the entire length of Ballantyne Commons Parkway. They no longer even mow the grass at 485 like Bissel did for two decades.

The second largest is Cato Farms Childress Klein which will plop nearly a 1,000 apartments into the middle of a single family detached development. This project will push 1/2 of their 6000 plus cars out onto Tom Short Road to find their way up Rea Road avoiding nightmarish Providence. 

Then there's the Rea Road Gillespie Property surrounded by wetlands and FEMA Floodplain on three sides. This magical oasis of natural forest is targeted to be wiped out and in it's place a 53 acre apartment complex and 4,000 cars dumped into the traffic along Rea Road and narrow Elm Lane.


Wednesday, February 7, 2024

SAVE THE DATE! Monday March 18, 2024 Charlotte City Council Meeting 5PM




Good Morning All - We Need Your Attendance & Support !!!!

NEW DATE Monday March 18th at 5:00 PM

Rea Road Gillespie Property City Council Rezoning Public Hearing

Charlotte-Mecklenburg Government Center

600 East 4th Street Charlotte, NC 28202

During this meeting City Staff will provide a brief summary of the Rea Road Gillespie Property rezoning request. The developer RK Investing Charlotte, LLC will then have 10 minutes to present their plan for the development of the property (apartment complex) to Charlotte City Council and the Zoning Committee. After which we have only 10 minutes to speak in opposition. 

This is our only chance to formally voice our concerns to Charlotte City Council.

Because our time is limited, what Charlotte City Council sees may be more important than what they hear, therefore it is imperative that we fill the Charlotte City Council chambers with people who care about our city and oppose this rezoning request.

We ask that you arrive early. Parking is provided at 232 S Davidson St Charlotte, NC 28202 directly across from the Government Center. 

We realize this is a big request just as our Carolina Spring gets under way but three hours of your time is far better than a lifetime of regret if we don’t show Charlotte City Council our resolve and unwavering opposition to this project.

As of this morning we are 19,293 signatures strong and now we need to show the Charlotte City Council that there are real people behind our petition.

Please mark you calendar for the event. This is your chance to be heard and seen.

Again, a big turn out for the event is critical !!!

Thank you for your continued support. 

Heartfelt thank you to Ward Welch for the use of his awesome photo of our majestic Eagle "Glen" guarding the nest tree last spring.

Sunday, February 4, 2024

Building Rules Verses Common Sense

 Gillespie Property South Charlotte Rezoning Petition


How would you feel if someone petitioned to build a casino, a prison or some other egregious project in your backyard??? 

“What is good for the developer and what is good for the community are often two different things. Just because a developer can meet a template of building requirements does not mean what is built is good, or even wanted by the community.”

What are we really talking about here???

If Charlotte City Council approves the RK Investments Charlotte, LLC rezoning petition RZP-2022-121 the developer will:

  • Clear cut more than 37 acres of old growth tree canopy from a Charlotte residential community.
  • Build a highly visible “large box” urban apartment complex that is nearly six times the density of the surrounding residential area on a hill featuring buildings that are five (5) stories tall. Little or no screening planned with setbacks in some cases as close as 15 feet to surrounding roads.
  • Add over 4,000 cars per day to the already overcrowded neighborhood streets, Rea Road, and Elm Lane.
  • Build at least 1,000,000 square feet of impervious surface, dramatically adding to an existing flooding problem within our local neighborhoods and along the Four Mile Creek Greenway.

At two well attended “Petitioner’s Community Meetings”, neighborhood residents let RK Investments Charlotte, LLC know loud and clear: 

“NO THANK YOU!”

Additionally, 19,000+ have signed a petition against the proposed zoning change. Countless Charlotte residents have made calls, and sent emails, making known their opposition to this rezoning request.

And yet, this developer has made NO effort to compromise with those neighborhoods affected.

Yes, zoning ordinances strongly favor builders yet at what cost to the infrastructure, citizens, neighborhoods, wildlife, and environment?  

Sometimes COMMON SENSE must prevail.

Mayor Lyles, City Council, City staff and Charlotte Zoning Committee, we respectfully REQUEST YOU DENY RK Investments Charlotte, LLC rezoning petition RZP 2022-121.

Your South Charlotte Neighbors

 

Please consider signing our Petition at change.org/savepiperglen

*(Pictured the Endhaven Road / Elm Lane property rezoned from single family to multi-family during the summer of 2023 is located just 1/2 south of the Gillespie Property).

A big thank you to Garland Green for this update.

Thursday, February 1, 2024

Elm Lane Flooding and the Gillespie Property

While concerns about stormwater hard surface runoff into Schitt's Creek, Mitchell Pond Number Six, Fourmile Creek are concerning our fears are not limited to Rea Road.


On the West side of the
Gillespie Property lies Elm Lane. A picturesque tree lined ribbon of asphalt that connects Ballantyne Commons Parkway to Pineville Matthews Road.

Just out of sight lies Stuart's Creek which runs along the east side of Elm Lane and then crosses under Elm Lane to enter the Ivy Hall gated community before transiting into a storm drain and running underground through the White Oak subdivision towards Pooh's Corner and the wetlands owned by Mecklenburg County and the White Oaks HOA. 


Stuarts Creek

Stuart's Creek starts at the Stonecrest Shopping Center, a Mecca for impervious surface. Then the creek collects more stormwater from 485. Unfortunately the addition of the 485 express toll lanes doubled the stormwater runoff into Stuart's Creek. 

As the water flows into Piper Glen golf course it empties in into the Par 4 No 14 pond. 

TPC Piper Glen No. 14 Par 4 Green

Leaving the pond via a spillway. Stuart's Creek flows north between the fairway and Elm Lane. 

TPC Piper Glen No. 14 Par 4 Fairway and Tee

Then in crosses under Elm Lane and heads toward Ivy Hall and the homes of White Oak.



This is where the trouble shows up. Ten years ago before the additional 485 lanes and the widening of Elm Lane and development south and north of 485 and at End Haven the water volume was somewhat manageable. 


Now even a mild ran causes standing water on Elm Lane. And if it is this bad now just think what this will look like with an additional 50 acres of impervious surface added by the Gillespie Property if it is developed as requested.