Saturday, January 13, 2024

Jaime Daniell for North Carolina State Senate

Those of you who have signed our “in person” VOTE NO petition on the Four Mile Creek Greenway may have met Jaime helping us tell neighbors why the Gillespie 53-acre forest is important to South Charlotte’s wildlife and residents alike.

Jaime has also been kind enough to allow our photographers to capture pictures of our Bald Eagles, Glen and Piper, from her backyard.



She’s a mom, a business owner and most importantly a Charlotte resident “who gets it done!”

One of our concerns about the Rea Road Gillespie Property Re-Zoning Request is the burden of additional traffic. Adding another 4,000 cars to Rea Road every day would be unbearable.

“Like you, I hate Charlotte traffic. We have to continue investing in roads and other transportation projects to relieve congestion, improve safety, and take the shackles off our economy. I will make sure Mecklenburg County gets its fair share of state transportation dollars.” – Jaime Daniell

We encourage everyone to VOTE in the upcoming Primary Election on Tuesday March 5, 2024 and hope you will consider Jaime Daniell for NC State Senate District 42. 

Jaime Daniell NC State Senate

Friday, January 12, 2024

Rea Road Gillespie Property Flooding January 9, 2024

The photos below are from the Tuesday January 9th rainfall. This location is on the Elm Lane or western side of the Gillespie Property.  At the location there is normally a slow trickle of runoff stormwater the comes from the southern half of the Gillespie Property and travels under Elm Lane via a 36 inch concrete pipe which empties into the Pooh's Corner marsh area. 













(We thank Mr. Garland Green for his photos above.)

On the east side of the Gillespie Property once the water in Four Mile Creek reached maximum capacity early during the rainstorm the water in Four Mile Creek started to flow backwards. Within just a few hours the water had pushed up the No. 11 fairway and over ran the clean pristine water of the small pond on the left side of the fairway. 



Above the view of the small pond on TPC Piper Glen No. 11 Fairway during the early fall. This pond is a frequent "fishing hole" for Heron, Egrets and our Eagles Glen and Piper. (Photos Courtesy of Steve and Carol)


 

Thursday, January 11, 2024

In Charlotte We Get Rain

Sometimes we go for weeks without rain, and sometimes we get a lot during back-to-back rainy days.

This past Saturday, we saw over an inch of rain. Then on Tuesday we saw 3.43 inches of rain in about 12 hours. The results were impressive or troubling depending on your perspective. 

Flooding was Everywhere

Yes, in Charlotte we normally see more rain than Seattle which averages around 38 inches annually. 

The difference is over in the home of Starbucks it comes at a slow nearly constant drip and in the Queen City it comes in random downpours.

In the last 365 days our Rea Road neighborhoods saw a total rainfall amount of 52.49 inches.

Which is why future development needs to be carefully thought out and more and denser is not always better.

During the last two decades Charlotte’s growth and impervious surface areas have expanded dramatically. This has created flood zones and areas prone to flooding that did not exist years ago.

In fact, the greatest concentration of FEMA Floodplains and Floodways in Mecklenburg County are located in South Charlotte.


FEMA Floodplain and Wetlands surround the Gillespie Property on 3 sides.

When developers are allowed to clear cut trees and reengineer the topography without regard for the surrounding terrain, we end up with stunning changes in flood flow.

Below is the stormwater flow off the Gillespie Property during the rainstorm on Tuesday January 9th.

Photo Courtesy of Garland Green

Photo Courtesy of Garland Green

Photo Courtesy of Garland Green

Thankfully the thick stand of mature trees on the property absorbed much of the rainfall, still the amount of rain overwhelmed Elm Lane.

Trees Prevent Flooding and Erosion

The Rea Road Gillespie Property developer has stated that there would be a possible 30% tree save on the 53-acre site. At first glance this seems reasonable since the city requires only a 10% tree save. In fact, the developer says this is more than generous.

However, this is pretty disingenuous, since 30% of the property consists of FEMA Floodplain and pond. In fact, exactly 15.9 acres of the 53 site or 30% of the property is unbuildable pond and FEMA Floodplain.

If the project, as proposed, is approved the developer would remove the remaining 70% of the native forested area and replace it with 37 acres of mostly impervious surface creating somewhere in the amount of 1 million gallons of run off every time it rains 1 inch. In other words, adding 1 million gallons to what you see in the above photos.

And so consider this: Over the twelve months ending December 31, 2023, Four Mile Creek reached ten feet, that is just short of the USGS Flood Stage, ten times.

 


But back in 2010 that same 10-foot mark was reached only 4 times. Between 2000 and 2015 the average is only 3 times a year. 

 

But in each of the last five years, that same ten-foot mark has been reached or surpassed at least ten times. Twelve times in 2020.


But in the decades prior, that ten feet mark was a rare event and flood stage even rarer. Today that once every 100 years FEMA flood mark, is reached every year.

 



It's Not Just Water

It is not just about the flooding and the water; it is about what is in the water (chemicals; petroleum products, pesticides, wastewater) and most importantly where it ends up. More than half the Gillespie property drains to the southwest and directly into the area known as “Pooh’s Corner”.  This small area is a pristine natural wetland that is home to endless varieties of wildlife.

Replacing the forested property with a massive apartment complex will destroy the fragile balance of nature's wetland habitat.

In the past developers could build whatever and wherever with little concern about the consequences. Now as the city grows internally, leaders, and developers need to be aware that their density staurating and infill development policies create tremendous strains on our environment and sometimes just saying NO is the best choice. 

 

Wednesday, January 10, 2024

The fate of plans for 3,900+ homes on 6 key sites looms in front of the Charlotte City Council; the latest on where things stand

 



Site plan for the controversial Gillespie rezoning in Piper Glen (left); map of The Ledger’s selections of the six hottest rezoning sites, with three close to the Providence Road corridor

by Tony Mecia

Nothing stirs the passions of Charlotte homeowners quite like the possibility of apartments down the street — and 2024 is shaping up to be a year of passionate debates over development plans.

As we enter the new year, there are a handful of big decisions looming in Charlotte over developers’ proposals that will determine the fate of a combined 3,900+ housing units around the city. Many of the disagreements hit on the familiar tension between the city’s need to build more housing and residents’ concerns over traffic, school crowding and open space.

We talked with Charlotte development insiders to compile this list of 6 key rezonings that will be coming up in 2024 and that will be blockbusters because of the level of opposition or because of their significance to the city. The City Council is expected to decide on these in the next few months.

Enjoy:

1) 640 homes in Piper Glen

  • Location: Piper Glen/Ballantyne; 53 acres at 9621 Elm Lane, between Elm and Rea Road
  • Proposal: RK Investments is proposing up to 640 homes on wooded land near the Four Mile Creek Greenway known as the Gillespie property — a mix of 500 apartments and 140 single-family houses and townhomes. The developer initially proposed 1,100 housing units but dropped the number after opposition.
  • Opposition: Neighbors have an online petition with more than 18,000 signatures opposing the rezoning. They say they worry about traffic and also cite environmental concerns, pointing out that two eagles live nearby. At a heated community meeting in September, some residents called out City Council member Ed Driggs to his face for taking contributions from developers. (Driggs replied: “I’m a moral person, and I can’t be bought.”)
  • What’s next: Public hearing scheduled for February
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥

2) 917 homes + middle school near Rea Farms

  • Location: Rea Farms area in south Charlotte; 125 acres at 11315 Tom Short Road, west of Providence Road and south of I-485
  • Proposal: Childress Klein and Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools are proposing 917 homes — 682 apartments, 211 townhomes and 24 single-family houses — plus a new middle school on land known as the “Cato property” that’s now woods and open space. A lawyer for the developer told residents it will be a “really high-quality community” within walking distance to commercial areas and to the school.
  • Opposition: At a community meeting last month, residents in the nearby Stone Creek Ranch neighborhood said they worried about the effect the new homes would have on traffic and stormwater runoff, and some criticized the apartments as being out-of-step with surrounding single-family neighborhoods. An online petition has about 2,000 signatures from residents opposed to the rezoning.
  • What’s next: Public hearing expected in February or March, at the earliest.
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥

3) 500+ apartments across from Charlotte Latin School

  • Location: Providence Road corridor in south Charlotte; 14 acres at 9631 Providence Road, south of Kuykendall Road, across Providence from Charlotte Latin School
  • Proposal: Developer C Investments 2 has assembled 7 parcels and is proposing a mix of market-rate apartments and affordable housing apartments. The numbers could change, but at a revealing online community meeting, the lawyer for the developer estimated it would be 425 market-rate apartments and 120 affordable apartment units in partnership with DreamKey Partners, in a four- to five-story building.
  • Opposition: According to the community meeting notes, nearby residents expressed concerns about the effects on traffic and tree preservation. Some also said the development wouldn’t fit in: “Several attendees stated that they believed a 4-5 story building does not meet the character or charm of the neighborhood,” according to the developer’s written account of the meeting.
  • What’s next: Public hearing expected by this spring.
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥ as of now; has been under-the-radar — could be upgraded to ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥

4) 1,500 homes + grocery store + office/retail along Providence Road

  • Location: Both sides of Providence Road near the intersection with Old Providence Road; total of 115 acres
  • Proposal: Three developers — Levine Properties, Northwood Ravin and Horizon Properties — have coordinated three rezoning petitions that they say would lead to the revitalization of an area that is decades old. When it was announced a year ago, developers said it would include a mix of housing types totaling more than 1,500 homes, including 225 affordable/workplace housing units. Developers have not announced the identity of the grocery store. The site encompasses the Crest on Providence apartments, the Gladedale apartments and the Providence Square Shopping Center
  • Opposition: Any opposition has been mostly muted so far. Some of the residents who would be displaced by having their 50+-year-old apartments redeveloped say they support the move, while others have said they wish they could stay.
  • What’s next: Public hearing expected in March or April at the earliest.
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥

5) 350 apartments in Steele Creek

  • Location: Steele Creek; 20 acres at 13607 Choate Circle, south of South Tryon Street, and east of Rivergate Parkway.
  • Proposal: Toll Brothers Apartment Living is proposing 350 apartments in four buildings, including one of up to 50 feet. It had originally proposed 375 units. It would include a half-acre public dog park. The land is currently home to the Piedmont Kennel Club, which says it’s in an old building and wants to sell.
  • Opposition: At a public hearing in August, one nearby resident said her main objection was “crimes from the apartment complex flowing into our neighborhood.” She also said owls live on the property. A youth sports association says it worries about the proposed development’s effect on adjacent ballfields.
  • Next steps: Council decision tentatively scheduled for Tuesday.
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥

6) Redevelopment of South End Business Park

  • Location: South End Business Park, near Clanton Road between I-77 and South Tryon Street
  • Proposal: Ram Realty Advisors has submitted a rezoning petition to allow the redevelopment of the South End Business Park with a mixed-use development. The rezoning offers few specifics and would allow for a mix of residential, office and retail, with a maximum height of 180 feet. At a meeting in July, the developer said the first phase would likely include multifamily residential, retail and open space to create “a loved place from day one,” according to an account of the meeting filed with the city. Office and hotel wouldn’t be in the first phase “given the economic market today.”
  • Opposition: No apparent opposition.
  • What’s next: Public hearing anticipated in February.
  • Ledger intrigue rating: ðŸ”¥ðŸ”¥

BONUS 7th REZONING: Wells Fargo sign

  • Location: 550 South Tryon building (former Duke Energy Center building)
  • Proposal: OK this one isn’t really development, but it’s interesting: Wells Fargo submitted a rezoning petition that would allow signs on the handle-bar-shaped top of the building.
  • Opposition: No formal opposition; a few snarky comments on social media at the time. It’s hard to imagine given the flurry of signs on uptown buildings that this wouldn’t go through.
  • What’s next: Public hearing sometime this year

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

Charlotte City Council Zoning Meeting Again Delayed

The Charlotte City Council Meeting for the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning hearing is now set for Monday February 19th in Council Chambers at 5:00PM.

The meeting was on the council docket for Next Tuesday January 16th. 

Please mark your calendars and plan to attend. (Note the meeting is the usual Monday meeting)

We need to show a united opposition and your in person appearance will speak louder than any words we can say. 



Our concerns remain as the developer has failed to address the following issues in any meaningful way:

Continuity of our neighborhood - Because the proposed project at 644 rental units is nearly 10 times the density of the surrounding area it does not provide for continuity of our neighborhoods, and simply doesn't fit. In short, the project is proposing urban zoning in a non-urban setting.

Preservation, Protection, or the Conservation of our Natural Resources - The proposed project does not address concerns about the loss of at least 70% of the 53 acres of old growth forest (Tree Canopy) bordering the Four Mile Creek Greenway which would be destroyed, or the likely damage to Four Mile Creek, the adjoining 13 acres of FEMA Floodplain, the surrounding 35 acres of Wetlands, as well as the local Wildlife Habitat. The loss of this property would be a loss for all of Charlotte and not just the Rea Road Community. 

Traffic - The City of Charlotte and NC DOT for years have failed to plan or fund roads in the area with any logical method. The result is a patch work of 2, 3 and 4 lane segments, poorly planned thoroughfares, intersections and an interstate with unfinished toll roads. Sidewalks and Bike lanes as well as Curb and Gutter systems that are not even in the planning stages. The solution in the past was to have developers provide band-aid fixes that lack forethought or planning. This project along with other proposed or already approved high density multi family rental properties in the area will add exponentially to the already existing traffic nightmare. 

Infrastructure - The future costs of the proposed project to the City and County regarding roads, schools, public safety, solid waste and other services, is unknown but far more than our current infrastructure and city budget can absorb. The development as proposed will cost CMS alone $5,674,000, and place additional staffing requirements on police, fire and medic as well as city and county services. Duke Energy is currently experiencing random power outages in the area due to unpreceded growth and demand. Outages that never occurred a decade ago.

We continue to ask that all Charlotte City Council Members VOTE NO and to deny this rezoning request. 

If you have not already signed our online petition we encourage you to do so by visiting http://change.org/savepiperglen

Thank you for your continued support.

Sunday, January 7, 2024

Rea Road Gillespie Rezoning a Clear Threat to our Environment

Builders across Mecklenburg County seem to have little regard for our environment. Most view compliance with silt fence and storm drainage mitigation measures as nuisance inconveniences. 

Mecklenburg County enforcement and state agencies are vastly understaffed and are simply unable to efficiently inspect construction sites. Broken construction silt fences and damaged temporary retention ponds are compounded by contractor's indifference. 

The small concrete pipe along the eastern side of Elm Lane seems innocent enough. After all what's a little run off water? But the pipe collects runoff stormwater from the east shoulder of Elm Lane and the south side of the Gillespie Property directing the collected water into the marsh area known as "Pooh's Corner" along the Four Mile Creek Greenway.


The seldom noticed wetlands border the Gillespie Property on the west side of Elm Lane total more than 36 acres. Mecklenburg County owns 24.78 of those acres, and the White Oak Homeowners Association owns the remaining 12.15. 


Once the water travels under Elm Lane it flows in a narrow channel through a small stand of trees and into the wetlands; where it feeds into a micro ecosystem that provides life to countless species of birds, waterfowl, mammals and aquatic life.


Above a lone cormorant suns itself after a morning of heavy rain at Pooh's Corner
as mallard ducks forage amongst the cattails. 

But the planned multiple year construction project is only part of the problem. The clear cutting of 70% of the 53 acre forest and subsequent replacement with countless acres of impervious surface bring even more catastrophic damage.

Even developing the property as zoned for single family homes presents problems, but at least the smaller scope of the project could be mitigated.

We continue to encourage Charlotte City Council to respect the recently adopted UDO and recognize that they have a duty to actively preserve, protect, and conserve our natural resources by VOTING NO on the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Request RZP 2022-121.



Monday, January 1, 2024

Letter To Charlotte Mayor, City Council and Zoning Committee Members

Help stop the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning Request. Send an email today to the following:

Charlotte City Council Members


Charlotte Mayor

Zoning Committee Members

Douglas Welton, Chairperson - douglas_welton@einsteinslegacy.com
Terry Lansdell - lansdell.tl@gmail.com
Shana Neeley - shneeley@yahoo.com
Will Russell - russellclt704@gmail.com
Clayton Sealey - cltdevelopment1775@gmail.com
Rebekah Whilden - rebekah.whilden@gmail.com
Fredrick Winiker  - charmeckrick@gmail.com

You can use our sample letter or write your own. Thank You!

Dear Charlotte Mayor, City Council Member, Zoning Committee Member:

I'd like take a moment to remind you of Charlotte Citizens' concerns regarding the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning (RZP 2022-121) request by RK Investing, LLC.

As of today more than 18,250 people have signed an online petition opposing this rezoning request.

We in south Charlotte are all very aware of the need for additional housing as Charlotte grows. However, the proposed "luxury high end rental apartment complex" offers nothing in the way of affordable or work force housing and does little to address the limited supply of homes (new or existing) on the market today within the City. 

The proposed project does not address concerns about preservation, protection, or the conservation of our natural resources including the 53 acres of old growth forest (Tree Canopy) which would be destroyed and the likely damage to the Four Mile Creek, FEMA Floodplain, surrounding Wetlands, or Wildlife Habitat (home to a nesting pair of American Bald Eagles named Piper and Glen) that would occur if the rezoning request is approved.

We are also concerned about the continuity of our neighborhoods because the Proposed Project is nearly 10 times the density of the Surrounding Area. In short, the project is proposing urban zoning in a non-urban setting.

Finally, the future costs of the proposed project to the City and County regarding roads, schools, public safety, and other services, is far more than our current infrastructure and budget can absorb. 

Please VOTE NO on the Rea Road Gillespie Rezoning Request RZP 2022-121. 

Sincerely,