Friday, March 31, 2023

Letter to Raptor Center

We were fortunate to have Charlotte's local National Public Radio Station WFAE take an interest in our concern for our two resident Bald Eagles. When the WFAE reporter said he was going to meet with the staff at the Carolina Raptor Center to understand more about the American Bald Eagle I assumed this was good news. I could have not be more wrong and disappointed.

From Nick's broadcast:

Inside the Carolina Raptor Center in Huntersville, President and CEO Erin Katzner checks on a pair of disabled eagles in an enclosure. She said Mecklenburg County has more bald eagles than you might think.

"I know that we have some on Mountain Island Lake, there's some up on Lake Norman. If there's good habitat, there's very likely to be bald eagles nesting in the area," she said.

The last measurement of Charlotte’s tree canopy found it has shrunk to cover 45% of the city, down from 49% a decade ago. Katzner said habitat loss is a concern, but also said bald eagles are skilled at adapting.

"You know, I've seen bald eagles live in fairly developed areas, and fairly undeveloped areas, so it's really hard to say if it's going to be an issue for those birds, and what exactly would need to be done to prevent it from being an issue," she said.

She thought there were a few steps the developer could take.

"If it were me, I would probably want to protect that lake, protect that water system, which I imagine they would want to anyway, and ensure that some of those large trees remain standing," she said.

Obviously those of us who are very concerned about our Eagles "Glen" and "Piper" were stunned. Erin Katzner could not have been more dismissive. The raptor center director basically tossed us and our birds under the passing CATS bus.

Chip Starr's response to her on air comments is as follows unedited.


Erin,

I just wanted to make you aware that the habitat we feel is at risk cannot be preserved by the developer ensuring that "some of those large trees remain standing".

 

As an example of what is at risk is a developer's project approved by the City of Charlotte last year and less than one mile west, that was once 53 acres of native North Carolina Forest.

 

Here is the before:


Screenshot (1027).png

and the unfortunate situation one year later.

Screenshot (1028).png

Even developers who promise to preserve trees pay only minimum fines if they don't, and the truth is developers of large projects seldom save trees and that clearly would be an issue.

  
While Bald Eagles are indeed admirably adaptive, we are fairly certain that the projected five - seven years of heavy construction while completing the eight apartment buildings, that will tower over 65 feet can not be mitigated with a couple of large trees and a dredged pond with a fountain.

Yes, there are eagles at Mountain Island Lake and a reported pair at the far northern end of the Lake Norman area, but that is hardly more than most people might think are in Mecklenburg County.

 

The North Carolina Wildlife Commission says there are 400 known eagles in the state and to me that seems substantially limited compared to say Florida's 1,500. More objectively with 100 counties and 400 known Bald Eagles, North Carolina has exactly four eagles per county which again doesn't seem like a lot to me.

 

Furthermore, the Mountain Island area you mentioned to WFAE is surrounded by nearly 2,000 acres of Mecklenburg County Forest and Nature Preserves. While here in south Charlotte there is the Big Rock Nature Preserve that has a nominal 18 acres, add that to a few miles of rather polluted trash strewn Four Mile and McAlpine Greenways and anyone with even limited common sense would understand this developer’s project is a terrible idea. 

 

Obviously, I'm rather surprised that you would trivialize our concerns not only for this nesting pair of Bald Eagles but for all wildlife and the challenges nature is facing within the southern part of Mecklenburg County. 

 

Frankly, I expected more from the Raptor Center in the way of advocacy.

 

Regards

 

Chip Starr

Perhaps a little harsh, she never responded. 
The staff at the Raptor Center are wonderful and dedicated. We have applauded their efforts in the past and will continue to do so in the future. For now we must accept the fact that Erin Katzner is an insufferable twit who has just cost the Carolina Raptor Center one of the  biggest potential donation sources they could have hoped for, the 854 homeowners of Piper Glen.  

Wednesday, March 29, 2023

Closing in on 10,000!

The online petition has passed the 9,000 signature mile marker and we are closing in on 10,000. 

But equally impressive are the nearly 800 comments we have received. The first 200 are here.  


Once we get to 10,000 citizens we will present a printed copy to each Charlotte City Council Member in hopes of persuaded them to stop the Rea Road Gillespie Property rezoning request.



Sunday, March 26, 2023

Opposing Views Correcting a Few Facts

The Rea Road Neighborhood Coalition is open to opposing views. 

However, some of the circulating mistruths about the Rea Road Gillespie Property rezoning request are really concerning:

Charlotte City Council Will Approve This Request Because The Democrats Have a Majority:

Ed Driggs excuse is that he is just one of two Republicans and democrats are committed to density housing. Mr. Driggs has repeatedly said "Developers have rights too".  Tariq Bokhari was doing is happy dance last week with the approval of the tear down of Trianon Condos to be replaced with a massive 11 story apartment tower and retail complex. Which means the if your home on Wickersham that you've owned for the last 20 years faced east the sun will rise no more. 

FACT: Ed Drigg's modus operandi is flawed and founded on the premise that developers negotiate in good faith. Nothing could be further from the truth. Presenting a project with a density that is 6 times that of any apartment complex in South Charlotte as your starting point is not a developer acting in good faith.

While Driggs is in an minority this is not a partisan issue. This is an infrastructure issue, a neighborhood quality of life issue and an environmental issue. 

If Charlotte approves this rezoning request it will have the needed votes because they don't listen or care to what the citizens say not because Ed Driggs is a republican.

The Eagles Don't Cross Rea Road or Visit the Gillespie Property

One local news reporter made it clear she'd been told the Bald Eagles, "Piper and Glen" never visit the Gillespie Property.

While conducting her on camera interview she relatedly asked, "Have you actually seen the Eagles visit the Gillespie property?" 

FACT: During the interview as if on cue, the male eagle "Glen" swooped over the reporter's head banked hard to the right gained a little bit of altitude crossed Rea Road and within a few seconds disappeared into the forested Gillespie property. 

A few minutes later he reemerged winging his way back across Rea Road holding a good-sized fish.

Yes. without any reservations this nesting pair frequents the Gillespie Property. It is as much their home as the Piper Glen golf course is.

The online petition is not representative of Charlotte.

Apparently, someone has claimed that the signers of the online petition are not from Charlotte but rather the global online community.

FACT: The petition has not been promoted outside of Charlotte. In fact, less than 1% of the signers are from outside the local area. Many of these are simply family or friends of Charlotte citizens. We are happy to allow media and elected officials examine the records for accuracy including name, dates, and locations. 

The Eagles Don't Live on the Gillespie Property their home is the Piper Glen Golf Course.

Odd thing about birds of prey they don't have addresses.

FACT: The Eagles have a "nest" on Piper Glen's golf course but their 'home" is an area that is nearly 3 miles across and includes all of the Gillespie Property. Once the eaglets fledge, they will only return to the nest off and on for a few weeks. The nesting pair Glen and Piper may return next January if undisturbed by the developer’s plans.

The Developer Will Save 40% of the Tree Canopy

FACT: There is absolutely no guarantee or enforcement process available to hold a developer to any promise of "saving trees". 

In this case the Developer's own plan simply states, "Possible Tree Save" and the reality is that like all development projects in Charlotte the trees are expendable. 

Developers will often promise to save trees then after wiping out all the tree canopy beg forgiveness, pay a small momentary fine and plant a few sapling trees as "replanted tree save" replacements as Russell Ranson has shown on the projects promotional material.

If you need proof look at Providence and Alexander Roads or Waverly. Given the scope of the project it is doubtful any trees will be saved.

The Development will extend the greenway.

FACT: The only extension of the greenway is a 75 foot pedestrian bridge that connects the proposed apartment complex to the Greenway. The developer has not indicated if access would be private or public, but they would need to comply with state and local design requirements if it was for the public. Additionally, liability insurance costs would likely be prohibitive to allow public access to private property. 

The developer's site plan illustrates an "extended" Greenway into the Piper Glen Golf Course area. This is an extension that would lead to nowhere even if built. According to Meck Park and Rec there are no funds or plans to extend the Greenway beyond Rea Road as shown on the builders presentation.

The Development will Provide Affordable Housing.

The developer has repeatedly described the property as "Luxury Apartments". 

FACT: There is nothing contractual about offering affordable housing. 

The Property Will Provide More Nursing Care in South Charlotte. 

One thing South Charlotte does not lack is the number of assisted living care facilities. 

FACT: There are more than two dozen within 5 miles of the Rea Road Gillespie Property, including Matthews Glen, Cypress, Brookdale, The Post, Waltonwood, Legacy and Southminister.

Traffic Increase will be minimal: According to Charlotte DOT if the property is developed as a "Senior Adult (Age 55+) property and nursing care center the traffic count will increase by 4,900 vehicle movements daily.  (We can assume perhaps double that if just an apartment complex).

Based on NC DOT Traffic counts there are currently 26,000 vehicle movements daily on this section of Rea Road. Adding the projected count of 4,900 and the tracffice count increases to more that 30,000 daily. That is a 20% increase, and hardly minimal. 

Thursday, March 23, 2023

A family of bald eagles — and traffic worries — spark rezoning fight in a wealthy Charlotte suburb


A bald eagle perches above the TPC Piper Glen golf course in the Piper Glen neighborhood on Thursday, March 16, 2023.
                       Photo by Nick De La Canal WFAE

It's a peaceful day on the TPC Piper Glen golf course in south Charlotte. A line of golfers practice their swings on the driving range as residents Chris McIntire and his wife, Ellie, stroll along the grass behind them.

Chris points to the sky, and Ellie raises her binoculars. Above them, a bald eagle swoops into view.

"That is Glen, right there, flying in," Chris says.

"Yep, one of them is flying in. Just landed," Ellie adds.

The eagle's nickname is Glen, the McIntires say, and his mate is Piper. The bird swoops into a tree in the middle of the golf course and perches beside a big nest of sticks and twigs.

"Probably brought lunch, or dinner," Chris says.

"Yeah, it's dinner," his wife says, looking through her binoculars.

The McIntires have lived on this golf course for 28 years. It's a generally quiet, safe and wealthy enclave, where the median household income of the area is almost twice as much as that of the county as a whole. They think the eagles have lived here for at least 12 years, raising eaglets every spring and catching fish in nearby ponds.

But the McIntires worry one of those ponds is threatened by a plan to build a six-story, 1,100-unit apartment community across from the golf course on land that's currently undeveloped.


                        Layna Hong / WFAE


"We're fearful not just for [the eagles], but for all the wildlife — the deer, the coyotes, the beaver, the owls, the Canadian geese that you see here in front of you," the husband said.

So, he started a petition, titled "Save the Eagles — Request Charlotte City Council vote NO on Rea Road Rezoning." But he says it's not just about the wildlife.
"We've also got to consider the traffic, the infrastructure, the strain on the streets," he said.

Opposition to new developments from neighbors worried about the infrastructure's ability to support an influx of people is common. A mating pair of eagles as the face of that opposition is not. So far, about 8,500 people have signed the petition. It asks the city to block the apartments, and keep the area zoned for single-family homes that won't "dramatically alter the character of the neighborhood."

Carolina Raptor Center weighs in

Inside the Carolina Raptor Center in Huntersville, President and CEO Erin Katzner checks on a pair of disabled eagles in an enclosure. She said Mecklenburg County has more bald eagles than you might think.

"I know that we have some on Mountain Islan
d Lake, there's some up on Lake Norman. If there's good habitat, there's very likely to be bald eagles nesting in the area," she said.

The last measurement of Charlotte’s tree canopy found it has shrunk to cover 45% of the city, down from 49% a decade ago. Katzner said habitat loss is a concern, but also said bald eagles are skilled at adapting.

"You know, I've seen bald eagles live in fairly developed areas, and fairly undeveloped areas, so it's really hard to say if it's going to be an issue for those birds, and what exactly would need to be done to prevent it from being an issue," she said.

She thought there were a few steps the developer could take.
"If it were me, I would probably want to protect that lake, protect that water system, which I imagine they would want to anyway, and ensure that some of those large trees remain standing," she said.


                              A bald eagle perches above a nest on the TPC Piper Glen golf course in south Charlotte on March 16, 2023.
                                Nick De La Canal  / WFAE


Developer says lake, open space will remain

When contacted by WFAE, developer Russell Ranson of RK Investors said his team was planning to do exactly that.

"We absolutely plan to preserve the lake, as well as a strong perimeter of trees that should fully disguise our buildings," he said.

Ranson said his team only wants to dredge the pond and maybe install a fountain, while keeping the fish in place.

He also said he hopes to preserve 40% of the land as open space for wildlife and walking trails, and said the impact on traffic would be minimal, according to a traffic study.

"I would just say we've been very thoughtful, and we look forward to visiting with the neighbors and hearing their thoughts and concerns. 

At the same time, we're trying to provide opportunity for a lot of families that need housing in this area," he said.

More than 200,000 people are projected to move to Charlotte by 2030, according to the U.S. Census. Ranson said if the city wants to accommodate that growth — and doesn't want real estate prices to keep skyrocketing — then Charlotte needs to keep building.

Tuesday, March 21, 2023

Charlotte City Council - Don't Mess This Up!

The following is an open letter to Charlotte City Council Members from one of many concerned Charlotte citizens opposed to the Rea Road Gillespie Property Rezoning:

March 21, 2023

Charlotte City Council members,

With regard to the Rezoning of the Rea Road Gillespie Property I respectfully submit this letter AGAINST its approval based upon the negative environmental impact it will have on our area.  

I have many additional reasons to oppose this rezoning, but for today I will stick with this one. 

I moved to the Touchstone neighborhood off Elm Lane in March of 2018 and appreciate the proximity to the Four-mile Creek Greenway immensely.  

More importantly, these birds do as well!

I took all these photos myself, right along the Greenway within less than a half-mile of my home.  

Photos Courtesy of Christine McCluskey all rights reserved.

A check of Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s eBird stats reveals that a whopping 160 unique bird species have been recorded in this part of the Greenway system (a summary list can be obtained here https://ebird.org/hotspot/L2425288)!  

Not all are rare, although some are becoming so.  

In 40 years, the once-common Rusty Blackbird lost between 85 and 95 percent of its population, making it one of the fastest declining North American Landbirds.  

The stunning Prothonotary Warbler is also in serious decline, due to loss of swamps and forested wetlands in the U.S.  

This community values sharing and maintaining our open spaces so that these animals can thrive here.  

The point is that we are currently able to coexist, and it is a testament to the general health of our environment that these birds call our area home.

Four-mile Creek Greenway with all its bikers, runners and walkers is already pushing the limits of capacity, and often struggles to manage the creek overflow during heavy rains.  

I find it impossible to believe that a huge 1,100-unit apartment complex on the edge of the Greenway will not drastically affect this fragile balance.   

Please do not allow them to mess this up!

Sincerely,

Christine McCluskey

Monday, March 20, 2023

Request For Submissions

Over the past few weeks we have achieved a tremendous amount momentum via a very strong collective effort. 

Having collected nearly 9,000 signatures in opposition and on air coverage from WBTV, WSOC, WJZY and WFAE we "neighbors" have made an impact.



So now that we have a firm grip on everyone's attention and in order to keep our effort to save the natural habitat of the Rea Road Gillespie Property in focus the Rea Road Neighborhood Coalition is asking for "submissions" of any type, including written letters, documents, articials, photos and videos. 

Just email your submission to rearoadnc@gmail.com full credit and rights given to all.

Even submissions in support of the rezoning and opposing views will be considered.

Sunday, March 19, 2023

Charlotte's Last Chance to Save a Little Green Space

OP - ED By Chip Starr

The Rea Road Gillespie Property is at risk. This land has remained undeveloped for the last forty years. But, as every trial attorney knows there are times when you just need to let the opposition talk:


Example when the developer says “There are no parcels of this size left in Charlotte,” as Russell Ranson with RK Investors recently told reporters. “It’s remarkable to have 50 acres inside of (Interstate 485) that have been undeveloped.”  

Its times like these we just need to let them talk.

Charlotte City Council needs to do the right thing and listen to Mr. Ranson. If they do, they will reject the rezoning request so as to protect this land for future generations.

But that's actually doubtful:

This what they did when Charlotte City Council signed off on a nearly identical "remarkable parcel" just 6/10s of a mile to the west last year.


Above is the 53.98 acre site that will become Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools next high school as it looked in January of 2022.

And below how it looks today.



So much for saving the "tree canopy" and guess who voted in support of the rezoning, in fact gleefully endorsed it? Ed Driggs, and he even commended the property owners for coming together with the developer.

Yes they agreed to have a high school football stadium and "Friday Night Lights" built in their backyard. But the council member is doing a happy dance?

Never mind that the property was zoned R-3 when the homeowners managed to save up enough money for the down payment on their modest homes.

The area to the left will also be wiped out and cleared for an apartment complex. Thank you Ed Driggs.

What is more troubling is that the project built a 1,500 foot retaining wall along the north and east side of the property and back filled the 20 foot tall wall. Which prevents future flood waters from over running the high school property but virtually assures that those same waters spread across a much narrower area than in the past posing a larger risk to the neighboring homes. 

This is not environmentally sustainable nor is it attractive. And the "Tree Save" area on the north edge of the property is actually nothing more than the unbuildable FEMA flood zone. 


The obvious rhetorical question is what is wrong with that? 

Well, for one thing the gratuitous nature in the way developers offer up these "tree save" compromises. Secondly because of the regularity with which this area now floods thanks to endless development, not only is this area unbuildable it also will not sustain the tree canopy as we know it today. Oak, Elm, Poplar and Maple don't tolerate "wet feet" and eventually will succumb to the repetitive and increasing floodwaters. It may take 30 years but one day the entire area will be a waste land of dead trees and marsh.

Do we stop the destruction of our tree canopy and in turn protect our environment? Or do we let greed and some less than honest city council members try to appease us with promises we know are hollow? Are we so hell bent of density saturation that we will ignore the environmental consequences of our actions? 

Well as Ed Driggs likes to say "Developers have rights too".