Tuesday, February 21, 2023

Let's Talk Density - How Much Is Too Much?

There has been a lot of talk recently about population density. 

Population Density creates a city and a neighborhood's character and quality of life as much as architecture and climate. 

New York City has twice the population density as Los Angeles. Which means that while shopping along 5th Avenue, you're likely to bump elbows with some stranger every 30 feet, but in Los Angeles while shopping along Rodeo Drive you might even find a curbside parking spot. 

 Above US Census Data NPA 262 and 181 and the Location of the Gillespie Property 

A quick search of US Census Data from 2020 shows that in Charlotte, NPA 181 and 262 make up much of Piper Glen. (Each NPA is a unique geographical area assigned by the US Census Bureau.)  

The site of the proposed David Gillespie Project and Rezoning Request is located in NPA 181 and 262 above. They are similar in size and have a combined area of 2,101 acres and include 6,072 residents. Which equates to a population density of 3 people per acre.

Above US Census NPA points for the Rea Road Area Neighborhoods and Gillespie Property 

If you step back a little further and include the surrounding neighborhoods that make up the Four Mile Creek Watershed and the Rea Road Neighborhood Coalition, you find that the population density increases to 4 residents per acre living on 6,680 acres.

County wide, Mecklenburg County has a population density of 3 people per acre. A total population of 1,115,482 residents, living on 349,491 acres, which gives Charlotte it's comfortable easy lifestyle and our wonderful Rea Road neighborhood's their character. 

It is also the reason both New Yorkers and Californians move to Charlotte.

David Gillespie wants to rezone the Gillespie Property with a density of approximately 3,300 people on just 53 Acres. That is a density of 63 people per acre versus the Rea Road Area's 4 per acre. Building 22 homes per acre in an area that according to Charlotte and Mecklenburg County has only one (1) home per acre.

Even the rather crowded nearby Arboretum Apartments, at Providence and Pineville-Matthews Road (US Census NPA 206) has a density of just over 11 residents per acre.

Want to learn more? Explore Mecklenburg County's Quality of Life Data Base.

Monday, February 20, 2023

Zoning Signs - Is Just One On Rea Road Sufficient?

I thought this was a good observation. Charlotte City Staff put a notice of Rezoning Petition sign up on Rea Road sometime ago. But the property address is Elm Lane does that still count?

And so one of your neighbors emailed John Kinley with the city and asked the following:

I'm inquiring about the Gillespie Property Rezoning Petition 2022-121 9621 Elm Lane Charlotte, NC 28277.

I noticed the yellow "Rezoning" sign a month or so ago on Rea Road but there's no sign on Elm Lane, the actual address of the property. Accordingly many of the residents of White Oak and other subdivisions along Elm Lane are unaware of the rezoning request. 

Was this intentional? Or just an oversight?

I look forward to hearing from you.

John Kinley's Reply:


We typically follow State law regarding rezoning signs which doesn’t require that signs have to be placed on every street front.   


We posted on the Rea, a major thoroughfare while Elm is a minor thoroughfare, however I do see your point that many residents along Elm may never travel Rea and see the sign.

 

I will look into this a bit more and see if we can get an additional sign posted.


Thank you for bringing it to my attention.

 

John Kinley

Project Manager, Entitlement Services Division+Rezoning

Planning, Design & Development
600 East 4th Street | 8th Floor| Charlotte, NC 28202
(704) 336-8311 | john.kinley@charlottenc.gov |rezoning.org | charlottenc.gov/planning

Ed Driggs On The Gillespie Rezoning Request

Ed Driggs Charlotte City Council Member and Piper Glen Resident posted with comment about an hour ago on Next Door:

This is City Council Member Ed Driggs.  I have made clear to the petitioner that I oppose this rezoning mainly but not only because of its excessive density.  

I did want to clarify the timeline for the process: there will be a Public Hearing no sooner than April, and the final Council vote will not occur until at least a month after that.  

During that time, staff will analyze the petition, including a traffic assessment, storm water engineering, public safety and numerous other factors.  

I have been in touch with the HOA steering group and will work with residents to ensure Council is aware of their concerns.  

Write to me at ed.driggs@charlottenc.gov if you wish to be added to a mailing list I will use to send out updates.  

I am also willing to attend neighborhood meetings to explain the process and how you can make your voice heard.  

Approval of this petition is not a foregone conclusion, you can make a difference

United States Department of the Interior Fish and Wildlife Service

This morning I contacted the United States Department of the Interior Fish and Wildlife Service seeking their input on the Gillespie property proposed rezoning and development. 


At present the Fish and Wildlife Service has no record of the project or communication with the noted Developers RK Investors Charlotte, LLC.

While provisions of both the National Environmental Policy act and the Endangered Species Act of 1973 may apply, there is no reason to believe that there at this point is any violation. 

According to Fish and Wildlife of concern in our area are the following:

Bald Eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus)

Bog Turtle (Glyptemys muhlenbergii)

Carolina Heelsplitter (Lasmigona decorata)

Georgia Aster (Symphyotrichum georgianum) 

Northern Long-Eared Bat (Myotis septentrionalis)

Schweinitz's Sunflower (Helianthus schweinitzii)

All which have the possibility to have adapted to the rather isolated woodland area just off Elm Land and bordering Mecklenburg County's Four Mile Creek Greenway.

Unfortunately neither The Department of the Interior or Fish and Wildlife have the ability to force the developer to conduct a study to determine the presence or the effects of development on any of the above species in the area. 

However it is their policy to encourage environmental surveys on projects like this, especially since the property is bordered by "wetlands" on nearly 3 sides.

Perhaps the City of Charlotte should request this?

Also If you haven't signed the petition please do so here. 

CS

Saturday, February 18, 2023

Advice From Charlotte Wildlife Stewards

My letter to Charlotte Wildlife Stewards and Donna's response follows:

Good Morning,

I (we) need a little advice and a lot of help.

There are about 800 homeowners in Piper Glen and at least equal that number in surrounding communities that for years have quietly enjoyed our local wildlife including a pair of nesting Bald Eagles named "Piper" and "Glen" without any real concerns. Now the 53 acre site next to the golf course is in danger of being rezoned into a sprawling apartment complex. 

Because the property in question has remained unchanged for the last 30 years, and because of the design of Piper Glen which took into account the wetlands and floodplains within the community, this last remaining untouched urban woodland bordering Four Mile Creek has become a haven for wildlife including Glen and Piper who often spend time at a secluded pond within the property before returning "home" to "their tree" on the other side of Rea Road.. 

We don't object to development, but this project will put nearly 1,100 apartments on 53 acres vs Piper Glen's 815 homes on over 850 acres and we fear the wildlife including our cherished Eagles are at risk.

Any advice, resources, recommendations you can offer would be greatly appreciated.

Respectfully

Donna's Response:

Your email is distressing and I've been thinking about it all day. Developers see wild spaces as "unused" and "vacant" land while you and I know they are full of life. Have you and neighbors documented the wildlife with photos or maybe even journal entries? Photos of the eagles may help in the case against rezoning. Here is an excerpt from the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act:

The Act defines "take" as "pursue, shoot, shoot at, poison, wound, kill, capture, trap, collect, molest or disturb."  Regulations further define "disturb" as “to agitate or bother a bald or golden eagle to a degree that causes, or is likely to cause, based on the best scientific information available, 1) injury to an eagle, 2) a decrease in its productivity, by substantially interfering with normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering behavior, or 3) nest abandonment, by substantially interfering with normal breeding, feeding, or sheltering behavior" (50 CFR 22.6)

And here is a link to the act: https://www.fws.gov/law/bald-and-golden-eagle-protection-act 

Developing those acres will surely interfere with the eagles' lives. There is a $100,000 fine (and possible prison) for violations and a developer may be willing to pay that amount if they will get a huge return on what they build (thus the high concentration of homes).

The fact that it is a wetland is important because of the beneficial role it plays in sequestering water and carbon, as well as providing wildlife habitat. Piper Glen was designed to have the wetland and it should be preserved. 

I wonder if there is a way for the NC Wildlife Resources Commission to do a wildlife survey of the property. If a threatened or endangered species of animal or plant is found it's possible the land may not be developed. Contact Rupert Medford, District Biologist at rupert.medford@ncwildlife.org, 910-975-0577 (cell) or 910-571-9747 (office).

I suggest you and your neighbors contact your city council representative, county commissioner, and NC House representative to voice your concerns. They are supposed to be working for you and the more neighbors you have to write letters and make phone calls, the more chance you have of having them listen and support you. Bombard them!  And go to city council meetings, especially the rezoning hearing. 

It's difficult to put dollars and cents on wildlife habitat. The truth is, wetlands and forests provide priceless services to us - trees produce oxygen, take up carbon, cool the air, prevent flooding and erosion, and provide homes for wildlife. 

I hope my suggestions are helpful.  It's an uphill battle with developers and I hope you are successful in preventing the destruction of this patch of wildlife habitat.

Kind regards,

Donna Bolls

President

Charlotte Wildlife Stewards

Thank You For Signing The Petition To STOP the Gillespie Rezoning Request

On behalf of Glen and Piper as well as your neighbors thank you for signing the petition. We have reached 2000 signatures and that is awesome.

Based on a bunch of feed-back we have started the ground work to create the "Rea Road Neighborhood Coalition.  This group is modeled after the Rea Colony Coalition formed in 2020 to address the concerns regarding proposed zoning changes at two locations north of Pineville Matthews Road. 

As a first step we have created an email address ReaRoadNC@gmail.com and hope that some of you will "volunteer" to help address concerns, gather information, share ideas and work out the logistics regarding meetings in the months ahead.

Any thoughts or input would be very much welcomed.

Chip Starr 

Friday, February 17, 2023

List of Email Addresses / Telephone Numbers for Charlotte Mayor Vi Lyles and City Council Members



Ed Driggs - District 7

 edriggs@charlottenc.gov

704.432.7077

 

Tariq Bokhari - District 6

Tariq.Bokhari@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3431

 

Marjorie Molina - District 5

Marjorie.Molina@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3432

 

Renee Johnson - District 4

Renee.Johnson@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3436

 

Victoria Watlington - District 3

Victoria.watlington@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3435

 

Malcolm Graham - District 2

Malcolm.Graham@ci.charlotte.nc.us

704.336.6105

 

Danté Anderson - District 1

Dante.Anderson@charlottenc.gov

704.336.4099

 

James Mitchell Jr. - At-large

James.Mitchell@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3430

 

LaWana Mayfield - At-large

LaWana.Mayfield@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3433

 

Dimple Tansen Ajmera - At-large

dimple.ajmera@charlottenc.gov

704.336.2777

 

Braxton Winston​ Mayor Pro Tem

Braxton.Winston@charlottenc.gov

704.336.3185